Roy Keane harshly criticizes Sir Alex Ferguson

In his Sky Sports commentary, the ex-captain of the Red Devils stated that the club’s dependence on past icons is the main barrier stopping MU from returning to its peak.

According to Roy Keane, the problem of Manchester United is not just on the pitch but originates from the way the club is managed at the top level. "Who do you see making decisions at Manchester United? Sir Alex Ferguson and David Gill (former CEO) are still clinging to the club like a bad odor,"Keane compared their presence to a lingering influence that prevents the club from truly reinventing itself.

Keane’s remarks gained more attention when interim coach Darren Fletcher admitted he called Sir Alex for advice and support before taking charge. According to the former Irish star, this clearly shows Manchester United has not decisively moved on from the past, unlike other major clubs that have long done so.

The disappointing 2-2 draw against Burnley recently has only intensified Keane’s criticism. He argued that the quality of the match was unacceptable for a team that once dominated the Premier League. Instead of acknowledging the weaknesses, many inside MU seemed satisfied, which Keane described as a vicious cycle mindset.

Roy Keane questioned the process of appointing managers at Old Trafford. He found it puzzling that Manchester United repeatedly gives chances to underqualified candidates, only to dismiss them after just over a year. "It’s almost like forgetting to check the CV. Of course, you need something to prove you’ve won titles or managed a team for a long time. But you must look the person in the eye and ask if they are truly the right one to lead us to success,"- Roy Keane continued his criticism directed at MU.

The former midfielder emphasized that in a big club’s dressing room, stars challenge the new coach from day one. If the leader lacks authority or fails to provide convincing tactical and strategic direction, players quickly slip out of control.

While Roy Keane expressed his frustration, Daniel Sturridge’s reaction on live TV became a highlight. The former Liverpool striker repeatedly covered his face to suppress laughter at the harsh criticism, and this moment quickly went viral on social media.

On the other hand, Sir Alex Ferguson received sympathy from some fans. The 84-year-old strategist currently holds no official role at Manchester United and cannot be blamed if a former player seeks his advice. Notably, in 2024, INEOS ended a multimillion-pound ambassador contract and limited Ferguson’s presence in the locker room area.